OllieSuave-007
This is one of the first Disney cartoon featuring Chip N'Dale. Here, they meet Donald Duck, which isn't a pleasurable first meeting as Donald chopped down a small log so he could light a fire in the bitter cold, unaware that the chipmunks were living inside.Donald is my favorite Disney character, so I don't like him being the brunt of all bad luck all the time. But, he does have some funny moments in this cartoon, especially where the snowball splashes in his face. The chipmunks' fast-talk was hilarious at times. Chip plays the more thoughtful and know-it-all chipmunk, while Dale is the more goofy and clueless one.I remembered watching this cartoon short as part of a video cartoon short compilation when I was a kid. I've always thought the cartoon shorts were funny when I was a kid, but became a little more partial toward Donald Duck as he became my favorite character and Chip N'Dale became more annoying. But, it's still a fun cartoon for the kids and good for any true fans of the chipmunks.Grade B-
MartinHafer
Despite the title, this is NOT the first appearance of Chip and Dale in cartoons. Instead, it's their third--and their first starring vehicle. When the film begins, Donald, ever the jerk, chops down Chip and Dale's tree. Naturally the pair resent this--plus he's stolen their nuts! So the pair go in search of their tree or at least what's left of it. The rest is a battle between the two rodents and Donald and, as you'd expect, they get the better of this grouchy bird throughout the cartoon. So is this a classic? Perhaps. I liked the cartoon and it's well made but it also lacks the wonderful sadism of Warner Brothers' comparable pair, Hubie and Bert--characters that were far less popular but whose nasty antics make me laugh car more than a Chip and Dale cartoon. Still, well worth seeing.
TheLittleSongbird
This is one of my favourite Chip an' Dale cartoons. It is lively and on the whole well animated. The animation is very colourful and vibrant, a couple of stiff movements here and there, but not at all bad. My only other minor criticism is that the story is very routine. The music however is lovely and memorable, and like in Toy Tinkers I loved it that Donald was made the antagonist of the picture. Chip an' Dale are as funny and as cute as ever, and Clarence Nash does a fine job voicing Donald. I may be biased for liking this, but I love Donald Duck, he is such a great character. There are some funny moments, one of my favourites was when Donald sticks his head into the fireplace and Chip an' Dale drop snow onto his head from above. All in all, lively and fun. 8/10 Bethany Cox
Robert Reynolds
This short, nominated for an Oscar in 1947, is probably the best Chip 'n Dale cartoon done. It helps that Donald Duck is the antagonist, giving the cartoon personality the title characters largely lack. The Warner Brothers creation of The Goofy Gophers is far more lively and entertaining for me.Worth watching
AD
