raganabahargawa-18200
This movie was so glorious and heart touching.One of the best movie ever made and one of my favorite film of all time.
Pazu Kong
The acting of both Jay Chou and Lunmei Kwai were naturally conceived and considering this is the first movie directed by Jay Chou, a talented singer and songwriter, I must say this is not a bad movie.The angles of shooting were also thoughtful, making it quite a pleasant viewing experience.But the plot was full of strange twists and the sense of sadness was created too deliberately, somehow not quite seamlessly fitted in the movie.Call me picky and I'm sure this was not Contact and Jay not Carl Sagan, but I still felt somehow bewildered by the storyline, the time traveling, the prolonged asthma of Hsiao Yu (Rain), the destruction of the school building, the music score of Secret, the magical power of the old piano, even the poem was a pretension to elegance.I hope I don't offend the fans of this movie, but I think this movie fits perfectly into the mainstream movie by giving you all the elements of sadness, fantasy, beautiful actress, handsome actor, good music and of course, romance. But with its obvious flaws, it is never a classic.
stutsb
Although I only watched it on Youtube...I loved the movie, I don't know why there are those who says Jay can't act, I say he can... I loved this movie. This is the only 2nd movie i have seen of Jay's, and I am a huge fan. I love his music, and his voice is so beautiful. As for his acting, it's rather good... I Love Love stories, and though this is two high school kids, I still love the fact that love has no boundaries, and can travel thru time. There is a similar American movie which starred Christopher Reeves (*aka* superman) and Jane Seymore (*aka* Dr. Quinn, Medicine woman) called somewhere in time, where reeves' character is obsessed with this woman from the past, and goes back to save her...It too is a sad ending, unfortunately, he comes back to the future, cuz he stuck a present day penny in his pocket which forwards him back to the future, and he couldn't' go back to see her...sad cuz he dies only to be reunited with her in death...Glad these two didn't die...Jay is so amazing with the piano. He has so much passion for music, it's a wonder he is so natural for this character that he creates from himself. I say beautifully done, I did have to get a box of tissues...Poor Rain when she thought Sky and Jay were together when she came back... So glad they got together ...They are so good together...I definitely have to add this to my collection now, and now I am a huge Jay Chou fan...and gotta get more of his music and movies!!!
robbendy
At his debut as a movie director ,Jay Chou has showed us what "perfect"is,just like what he's always bringing to us in his extraordinary pop music.As the hottest pop star in China,all the time Jay Chou is suffering all kinds of criticism,even virulent personal attack. However,he never gives in facing the rumors and never gives up pursuing his dreams ,including creating music and movies of his own,some of which has come true.Jay has a biggest target that he wishes to make Chinese pop music world-famous before he's 30 .No matter whether the target can be reached,he's the best,which is the most important.
AD
