g_dekok There was a General William Barksdale from Mississippi, who died at Gettysburg. I caught the cadet's last name, and wonder if it was a play on words, or was the young man his son? Anyone?

Edgar Allan Pooh . . . William Holden demands of John Wayne halfway through THE HORSE SOLDIERS. I've always wondered what the technical term is for the odd-looking "Dagwood Bumstead"-style chest garments Mr. Wayne seems to affect for most of his flicks (whether he's supposed to be a civilian, or again if he's supposedly in the Pre-"Don't ask, don't tell" U.S. Military, as in THE HORSE SOLDIERS). The closest that I've seen any other actor come to Mr. Wayne's iconic upper body costumes has been George Lazenby as "James Bond," in ON HER MAJESTY'S SECRET SERVICE. While Mr. Lazenby's top may have had an extra flourish compared to "Il Duce's," Mr. Holden's word "blouse" certainly seems an apt description of both men's upper garments. There's probably enough thanks to split between Mr. Holden, the HORSE screenwriters, and director John Ford for finally setting the world straight about Mr. Wayne's orientation. Even many of today's commentators won't touch this topic with a ten-foot pole, fearing that the reach of Hollywood's most famous Bully Boy (see TRUMBO) may even extend from the Grave. However, a lot of sound bites have been released recently from another of "Il Duce's" directors, William A. Wellman, which back up William Holden's insinuation in HORSE.

denis888 John Ford dismissed this movie but in vain, this is a very decent work, a very dynamic and even humorous take on Civil War. John Wayne did a very good job here as Colonel Marlowe, and his performance is very deep, convincing,often wild, often touching. This is not his best work, as say, in The Longest Day, but still, John did a very candid work in here. Another highlight is William Holden as a military medic Henry Kendall - his play here is one of the real crowning achievements of the whole movie. I was surprised to learn that John Ford somehow rued the work, as the movie is really very enjoyable, a good and healthy combination of war and romance, espionage and cowardice, hate and compassion. The battle scenes are incredibly fine, too, the Confederate Railroad station attack is deeply moving and worth Maxwell's grandeur. Watch this movie and you won't be really disappointed, this take on the War is good, honest and rather dry, but realistic

jpdoherty John Ford's THE HORSE SOLDIERS is something of an underrated cavalry epic from the great director. Produced in 1959 for a United Artists release by John Lee Mahin and Martin Rackin it was nicely written for the screen by Mahin and Rackin and colourfully directed,if a little less auspicious, by Ford. Beautifully photographed in widescreen and colour by William Clothier the picture also benefited from an atmospheric score by David Buttolph which was made up from an array of rousing cavalry songs. Once again John Wayne was the star and making his one and only appearance in a Ford picture is the surprise casting of William Holden who, it has to be said, is much less flamboyant here than usual especially if you consider his marvellous Captain Roper in the excellent cavalry western six years earlier "Escape From Fort Bravo". His role in THE HORSE SOLDIERS, as the non-combatant regimental doctor, is almost totally overshadowed by the arrogant and irascible troop commander as solidly played by Wayne. Never reaching the lofty heights of Ford's memorable triptych of cavalry epics "Fort Apache", "She Wore A Yellow Ribbon" and "Rio Grande" THE HORSE SOLDIERS is nevertheless an engaging Civil War adventure.The story of THE HORSE SOLDIERS is based on a real incident during the Civil War in 1863. Under orders from General Grant a division of Union cavalry, under the command of Colonel John Marlowe (Wayne), are to cross over into Alabama and Mississippi in the South and destroy the railway line at Newton Station deep in enemy territory which is the main supply depot of the Confederacy. On completion of their mission they are to make their way to safety via Union held Baton Rouze. The mission starts out and proceeds with little difficulty until disagreements erupt between Col. Marlowe and the regiment's doctor Kendall (Holden) who has been sent with the division against the wishes of Marlowe who distrusts and dislikes the medical profession. And then there's the beautiful Southern Belle (Constance Towers) who, eavesdropping, overhears the Union's plans and must now be taken along with the regiment lest she informs the enemy. The picture ends with an exciting battle between the two sides - the Union army routing the Confederates and making their escape to Baton Rouze.Performances are splendid from all concerned. Wayne is especially good bringing great authority to his role. His Colonel Marlowe is arguably his best cavalry portrayal. Wayne's presence gives the movie a certain sheen and actually makes the film better than it really is. Holden is good too if somewhat more tempered than in anything he did before (He never handles a weapon throughout the film). But the antipathy between the two men makes for some engaging confrontations (the usually reticent Holden throwing a drink in Wayne's face, squaring up to him and yelling "OK section hand - I've had it - strip your blouse"). Regretfully though, and despite appearances by Ken Curtis and Hank Worden, there is a noticeable absence of Ford players. Particularly missed are Ben Johnson and Harry Carey Jn. But there is a nice bit of casting for General Grant at the beginning of the movie who is played by cavalry song writer Stan Jones. Jones composed the movie's featured song "I've Left My Love". And it was Jones also who, three years earlier, had written "The Song Of The Searchers" the stunning ballad sung by The Sons Of The Pioneers over the titles of the Ford/Wayne classic "The Searchers". Also of note is the casting of Althea Gibson in the role of Tower's coloured servant. Gibson was a champion tennis player. She was the first African American to win the Grand Slam in 1956 and was the first African American to play Wimbledon in 1951 and to win it in 1957.Ford's picture is a handsomely mounted adventure with some blazing action from time to time. Not as good as some of the director's previous cavalry epics but thanks to Duke Wayne for being around and contrary to general opinion THE HORSE SOLDIERS is an enjoyable ride.