Jackie L.
What an incredibly fascinating documentary. I'm in high school debate at a school much like the ones shown- yes, we're in Texas- and the story shown is scarily accurate. It's more than entertaining to see the more unusual aspects of debate highlighted, like foot-tapping and spreading.For those who oppose spreading, that's understandable, but in many ways, it's necessary. Debaters are always told to decide for themselves how they should present their case, depending on the type of judge they have. In a round in which everyone can understand each other, a fast pace simply means more arguments and evidence. It definitely isn't ideal for the average person to comprehend, but as for training speech and eloquence, it is more helpful than imaginable. You have no idea how concise and clear your arguments and everyday speaking becomes after training to speak coherently at hundreds of words per minute. Also, you gain a well-developed sense of self-being and confidence from speaking on issues that are very much applicable to the real world.However, I very much agree with the kids from the urban league, because debate nowadays is focused far too much on the structure of debate- topicality, etc.- which only detract from the true debate. It's less of an argument on theories and morals and more of an argument of if the other team follows the rules or not. Ridiculous impacts are named to win rounds, and the experience strays from true intellectual discussion. If there is anything I could change about debate, it would be the easy ways out; using cheap tricks to win rounds and avoid ideological debate does NOT mean that you are a good debater.Either way, this movie is fantastic, and it's easily watched. For those who think debate is boring, check this out and think again. :]
judeobscur
This film was great because it brought back a lot of memories. It'd been so long that I'd forgotten how much work went into preparing for and attending the many many many tournaments. And it'd been ages since I'd heard someone talk about the "tab room." For folks who are not familiar with competitive debating, the type of debate featured (team debate) is not the only type. Alongside team debate at the same tournaments is Lincoln Douglas debate which involves individuals competing against each other in a far more eloquent manner. No speed reading. No trying to "out flow" the other person. I found Lincoln Douglas debate to be invaluable training for the real world.For parents who see the film, I hope you encourage your kids to try debate. It can be the high pressure competition shown in the film, but it can also be about fun, friendships, and gaining confidence. Most importantly...stay involved! These schools and students need parents to help transport kids to tournaments and to judge competition rounds.
chillzkid
Richard and Louis were awesome! A must watch movie if you are a documentary fan.Debates should be about meaning not words!Thought the social message of the movie was great, and every educator and school should watch this documentary.It made me feel ashamed of the establishment. Also I cannot believe people actually do the meaningless speed talking.Maybe they should stretch the time period beyond 3minutes if kids have to talk that fast.Feels like an auction house.Debates should be about Meaning. And outsmarting your opponent, not just about out talking them.
knownwilderness
I had the good luck to see this film at the Los Angeles Film Festival. I have to admit that I was not a high school debater and know nothing of the activity, but I am glad that I went to see this film ! It is about so much more. I was completely moved by the students at Long Beach Jordan and their coach. It is a shame the Los Angeles School District does not support educational activities that truly challenge the mind. The students from the well-to-do school in Texas were just as fascinating with their own brand of outlaw mannerisms. I hope that kids from high schools all over the country will have the chance to see this film.Where will it screen next ?