Grumpy
For many years, I measured ALL movies by "The Bounty Test." The question is asked regarding a newly released movie--does it contain any elements of The Bounty? If it does, then I'll look forward to seeing the movie. If not, I'm much less inclined to want to see it. For example. If any members of this stellar cast are in the movie under consideration, I'll consider making a trip to see it in a theater. No Bounty veterans in this film? Meh. Or if the movie is about men on a ship (space ship, submarine, whatever) I might see the movie on the big screen. No? I'd go under protest. Music by Vangelis? It passes The Bounty Test. Directed by Roger Donaldson? Yes, it passes. Filmed in Tahiti? I'll see it.This test is not fool proof. There are films that pass The Bounty Test that are not very good. But the fact that I used this film as a benchmark should indicate that this is no ordinary movie. It's a one of the last great period pieces. It tells an important story about what happens to young men from uptight cultures who suddenly find themselves plunging into non-uptight, um, "cultures." Mutinies may occur...I give this movie ten stars and a full recommendation, but only if you're a guy like me. My Bounty Test was, and is, highly subjective. Also, it doesn't always work. But for me, this film is a true classic. None better. Brilliant in ways that didn't happen due to planning, I don't think. It just came together perfectly. What more can I say?
leplatypus
I'm sure i got my taste for ship travels, pirates, exotic island and English Navy thanks to the library of my poor grandmother. It was before American comics and she got only a few books to offer us and among them, i think there was Treasure Island, Robin Crusoe and a team of animals seeking a treasure ! With this movie, i feel immediately this special wind which wasn't the case with « pirates of Caribbean ». Here, the production feels real, rich ; the locations are beautiful and the natives are indeed exotic. Thus, Mel's romance seems authentic and i really understand his passion to stay unlike Hopkins. In a way, the key to understand the movie (and my summary) is here: the prestigious captain grasps the daughter while the simple aid wins the beautiful one! In addition, the movie offers surprises, adding to Mel and Hopkins, young Day-Lewis and Liam Neeson ! And maybe you will be seasick because the life aboard a ship is well done : it's claustrophobic and overcrowded : in a way, you can't get mad without being noticed ! It's also a good illustration about authority : this is a strange power build on imagination and consent of everyone because when the numbers wake up, they can take it back from the individual.
Wuchak
The 1935 black & White version of "Mutiny on the bounty" may have won an Oscar for Best Picture at the time, but will likely strike modern viewers as dated and unrealistic. Marlon Brando's 1962 remake is the most epic, captivating and compelling version even though it failed at the box office when released; indeed the '62 version is a masterpiece (see my review). But Mel Gibson's 1984 version, simply called "The Bounty," is the most historically accurate and realistic film version of the infamous mutiny.THE PLOT (***SPOILER***): The Bounty mutiny story is so fascinating because it's TRUE. William Bligh, as acting captain, was sent on a mission in December 1787 to bring breadfruit plants from Tahiti back to England. Bligh intended on circumnavigating the globe in fulfilling the mission. Unfortunately he and his crew failed to get around Cape Horn, South America, and had to go the long way around Africa. It thus took them 10 months to reach Tahiti, wherein they were forced to stay another 5 months due to the breadfruit's "dormant" period. The natives were friendly and the women beautiful. It comes as no surprise that the crew naturally fell under the spell of the Polynesian paradise; Fletcher Christian even married the King's daughter, Maimiti. But after 5 months they had to get on with their mission and return to Naval discipline and England. Three and a half weeks later on April 28, 1789, Fletcher took over the ship with 18 other mutineers. 22 remained loyal to Bligh and 2 others were neutral. Christian set Bligh and 18 loyalists adrift in the ship's launch boat and then sailed back to Tahiti where he dropped off 16 men but picked up 6 Tahitian men and 11 native women, including Maimiti. Fletcher then set forth with 8 other mutineers and the Tahitians to elude the Royal Navy, ultimately settling on Pitcairn Island, which was well off the beaten path and misplaced on Royal charts, seemingly a perfect hiding place to live out the rest of their days (***END SPOILER***.WHAT WORKS: As already stated "The Bounty" is the most historically accurate version. It also has the most realistic vibe, which isn't to say that the '62 version isn't believable, it's just that this '84 version strikes the viewer as completely REAL. It's almost as if the film takes you back in time to view the actual events.This version also gives the most balanced and positive portrayal of the infamous Captain Bligh, played by Anthony Hopkins to great effect. Indeed the film stresses that he was exonerated in the matter. But it also hints of his character flaws that ultimately provoked the mutiny. In real life Bligh had a bad temper and was abusive & insulting to his subordinates. The other two versions show an event that really happened on the Bounty: two big cheeses came up missing on the ship and Bligh unjustly blamed and punished members of his crew even though it was he himself that stoled them!Perhaps Bligh's biggest flaw was that he lacked the ability to inspire loyalty in others; by all accounts he was a real bastage to be around when he was in authority. Lending credence to this is the fact that, even though he was exonerated in the Bounty case, he provoked ANOTHER mutiny years later in New South Wales, Australia!Despite all this Bligh was certainly a brilliant seaman and navigator. The film shows this with Bligh and the 18 loyalists on the adrift launch. After failing to settle on near islands due to unfriendly natives, Bligh navigates the small craft over 3600 miles to Timor in 47 days on very few provisions. He didn't have any charts or compass. All he had was a sextant and a pocket watch. Although all of the loyalists survived this incredible journey 5 later died due to ailments sustained in the voyage. The '62 version barely addresses this miraculous event but "The Bounty" devotes quite a few scenes to it.The score by Vangelis is very fitting. The best part of this composition is heard during the end credits. The film shows Fletcher, the mutineers and the Tahitians stranded on Pitcairn as they sadly observe The Bounty go down in flames. They know they can never go home again. Vangelis' unique piece then plays out over the credits. It perfectly captures the mood and setting. It's so magnificent sometimes I just play the end credits sequence. It's definitely one of the most emotionally potent endings in motion picture history.WHAT DOESN'T WORK: Although Gibson is more realistic as Fletcher Christian than Marlon Brando, especially since Gibson was closer to Christian's real age of 23-25 (Brando was 36-37 during filming), Mel simply lacks Brando's captivating charisma.The Tahitian scenes seem to lack pizazz; the film almost crawls to a halt (which is the the exact opposite of Brando's version). It doesn't personally bother me because the film is attempting to show us what leads to the mutineers' decision to take the ship, but some viewers may have a problem with it, in particular those with ADD."The Bounty" also fails to give any glimpse of what life would offer the mutineers & Tahitians on Pitcairn Island. The '62 version, on the other hand, devotes a number of scenes to this part of the story. This is not a negative to me, however, since showing subsequent scenes on Pitcairn would ruin the powerful end sequence noted above.FINAL ANALYSIS: "The Bounty" is the most historically accurate and realistic version of the infamous mutiny even though Brando's version is the most epic, engaging and compelling. I recommend seeing both versions back to back, which is what I usually do. Both versions are amongst my favorite films of all time. In fact, I consider them masterpieces.The film runs 2 hours and 12 minutes; Brando's version is 3 hours.GRADE: A
AaronCapenBanner
Roger Donaldson directed this superb film, a remake of the 1935 original that had starred Clark Gable & Charles Laughton. Here, Mel Gibson & Anthony Hopkins play friends turned bitter enemies Fletcher Christian and Captain Bligh, who sail the Bounty on a trading mission to Tahiti, where most of the crew are seduced by this paradise of great weather, abundant food, water...and beautiful native women. After leaving the island, Christian leads a mutiny, takes over the ship and goes back to Tahiti, setting Bligh and his loyal officers adrift, where they amazingly survive horrendous conditions, and Bligh leads another ship back there to punish them, though they had already left for parts unknown... Well-acted, directed, and scored film vividly shows the futility of mutiny and desertion, and the high price the mutineers will face. Fine script evenly balances the stubborn but honorable Bligh with the equally determined but erratic Christian. Can hold its own against the Academy Award winning original, and deserves to be better known and acclaimed.