Maddyclassicfilms The Hanging Tree is directed by Delmer Daves and Karl Malden. The film has a screenplay by Wendell Mayes and Halsted Welles which is based on the novel by Dorothy M. Johnson. The film stars Gary Cooper, Maria Schell, Karl Malden, George C. Scott and Ben Piazza.I was very impressed with Cooper's performance here. Frail is a much darker and complex character than we are used to seeing Cooper play. I loved his scenes with Maria Schell. The title song by Marty Robbins is extremely catchy; once the film is over, go back and listen to the song again, it is all about Frail and the story about to unfold.Newly arrived Doctor Frail(Gary Cooper)saves the life of a gold thief(Ben Piazza). He then makes the other man work for him in return for the Doctor's silence about the crime. A young woman called Elizabeth (Maria Schell)is injured during a stagecoach robbery, Frail tries to look after her and protect her from the unwelcome attentions of a local man (Karl Malden). Frail finds himself struggling with his own growing feelings for Elizabeth.The film keeps you guessing until the end about the true nature of Cooper's character. Malden is excellent as a lecherous local who tries to take advantage of Schell's character. George C. Scott appears in his film debut, he plays a faith healer who hates the fact that Doctor Frail is taking away his customers.Good performances all round, and some stunning location work help to make this a must see.

dougdoepke No need to recap the sprawling plot.For a western, the movie is generously produced. The Washington state locations are scenic as heck and a great backdrop to the rushing crowds and boisterous miners. In fact, the gold camp recreation is one of the most realistic I've seen. Then too, the production has one of the most underrated directors of westerns of the period, Delmer Daves, whose list includes such classics as 3:10 to Yuma (1957), Jubal (1956),and the generally overlooked Cowboy (1958). All of these are tightly written and efficiently directed little gems.But I have to say that despite the first-rate production values and a first-rate cast, this more epic sized western doesn't achieve the impact of Daves' smaller movies. The problem is a loose script and a dawdling camera that stretches out the dramatics and the movie's length to a sometimes tedious degree. I'm guessing that Warner Bros. wanted a production equal to Gary Cooper's iconic standing. I suspect they were also promoting newcomer Schell's career, and thus much time is split between her, Cooper, and the always reliable Malden. All perform well, but add up to bits and pieces that don't fit together very well, while padding the screen time unnecessarily.I wish Scott's truly fearsome religious zealot had gotten a bigger role. He might have made the movie memorable, so strong is his spotty presence. Something I don't usually notice in films is the movie score. But here the music is blended nicely into the screenplay, without overdoing it. Perhaps revealingly, this is Daves' final western. From here, he went on to teenage fare, such as the blockbuster A Summer Place (1959) that despite its teen angst of the day is not without notable compensations. Anyway, this film's a scenic delight at the same time the narrative unfortunately is not, which adds up to a very mixed result.

Spikeopath The Hanging Tree is directed by Delmer Daves and adapted to screenplay by Wendell Mayes and Halsted Welles from a story written by Dorothy M. Johnson. It stars Gary Cooper, Maria Schell, Karl Malden, Ben Piazza and George C. Scott. A Technicolor production, film was shot on location at the Oak Creek Wildlife Area, Yakima, Washington, with Ted D. McCord on cinematography duties, and Max Steiner scores the music.The Gold Trail, Montana 1878. Joseph Frail (Cooper), Doctor, Gambler and Gunslinger, arrives in the Gold mining town of Skull Creek looking to settle down and make a living. However, his past haunts him and after medically aiding Rune (Piazza) and Elizabeth Mahler (Schell), subsequently changing their lives, Frail finds this town and its people are less than enamoured with his presence.Slow but compelling, The Hanging Tree has a unique feel to it on account of its interesting location setting, the Gold Rush backdrop and the multi stranded characters that form the story. Not given much support at the box office on its release, it's a film that has gained a cult following over the years and it's now often referred to as an intelligent Western. The performances are smart, from a very good cast, and the story manages to steer away from conventional Western movie pitfalls. But what marks it out as a must see for Western fans is the work of Daves (and Malden who stepped in while the director was hospitalised with ulcers), where the expansive scenery is utilised for both authentic impact on the narrative, and also for the emotional conditioning of the characters.Personally I think it falls some way short of the great intelligent and psychological Westerns crafted by Boetticher and Mann. Yes there are complexities to the characters, but the script doesn't quite dig deep enough into them, which is particularly galling as regards Cooper's portrayal of Frail (an appropriate name given Coop's ailing health at the time). It's credit to Cooper that he still manages to bring the viewer into his pained world, helping to make the impact of the finale far better than it had any right to be if taken as written on the page. But it still rounds out as a thoroughly absorbing picture, one that's beautifully shot and scored with gusto by Steiner. Lovely hummable title song from Marty Robbins as well. 7/10

vincentlynch-moonoi I watched my share of westerns when I was a kid, but as an adult, it's a rare western that can hold my attention. This one did.Gary Cooper plays Joseph Frail, a strange mix of a doctor, a gambler, and perhaps a gunslinger. As he rides into a new town he rescues Rune, a sluice robber, from Frenchy (a dirty and nasty man played well by Karl Malden), and makes the young sluice robber an indentured servant. A stagecoach robbery results in the disappearance of Elizabeth Mahler (played well by Maria Schell). She is found by Frenchy (as part of a search party), and he has immoral designs on her. Her time in the wilderness led to skin burns, temporary blindness, and dehydration from overexposure. Dr. Frail treats her, but, as he has a tendency to do, he becomes possessive, and eventually Mahler leaves his protection and teams up with Frenchy and the sluice robber, and they strike gold. Frenchy attacks Mahler, and Frail kills him, resulting in Frail being on the verge of a lynching. Mahler saves him by offering the lynching party all their gold. Cooper is superb here...perhaps one of his best performances. In fact, it's difficult to find a less than good to great performance in the whole film. Definitely one to watch!