christopherclarke This film was made near my home village and like most Northern Irish films, it was a totally disappointment, as it simply pampered to the Americans on every level. The acting was horrible, the cinematography was film student quality and even the transfer of the footage looks like the film was shot with cheap camcorders. It made the people of Ireland look like drunken unemployed morons who still live in white washed cottages... talk about being stereotyped. When one compares this to "Six Shooter" (another Oscar Winning Short Film from Ireland)... one has to question the merit of the selection process of the Oscar.... A load of bland, uninspiring rubbish!!!

Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de) "The Shore" is an Irish short film that runs for slightly under half an hour and is mostly known for winning an Academy Award 4 years ago. I have not seen any of the 4 other nominees, but I am quite happy about "The Shore" winning as the film delivers on a comedic as well as emotional level. It is about two men who were friends when they were much younger, but politics and personal stuff got in the way at some point and they did not see each other for a very long time. Conleth Hill ("Game of Thrones") and the pretty famous Ciarán Hinds play the main characters here and they give the film the right note of rough, masculine, self-confident men who also have a soft side, which is mostly hidden. Typically Irish. On one or two occasions, it gets a bit too much of a sob-story, but overall, it is a very fine watch. Sucks to see that Terry George did not really manage to build a lasting career on the success of this short film. Then again, there was not a lot of success outside of the Academy Awards. only one other nomination is listed and the Irish Film and Television Awards did not even like the film enough to honor it. But I did. Check it out if you can. Quite strong little movie.

blind-sniper This film typifies everything that is wrong with Northern Ireland and its perception by the outside world. Every single Irish cliché is trotted out over the course of this 30 minute derivative, unoriginal, uninspiring husk. There's the backward village with its white washed houses, the quirky local who is always happy to give unintelligible directions,people drinking Guinness,lots of breaking into song, bad teeth, the troubles and its aftermath and even a reference to the titanic (Needless to say Belfast has more to be proud of than building a ship that was a disaster.) The film is a disgrace as it shamelessly panders to the ignorant (largely American)perception of Ireland, failing to distinguish between North and South, as a green land of inarticulate beer swilling simpletons. I fully expected to see a leprechaun make an appearance but perhaps that cameo is saved for the sequel. The very fact it won an Oscar is testament to the academy's lack of vision and parochial instincts. As a Northern-Irish man myself I can proudly say the country I live in is nothing like that portrayed here. It is a dynamic, evolving society with its own distinct culture. In the words of David Homes, a Belfast born musician: This film's bad,let's slash the seats.

MartinHafer I just completed my yearly pilgrimage to see the Oscar-nominated Live Action Shorts--tomorrow it's the Animated Shorts. This was a very unusual crop of shorts this year, as three of the five nominees were comedies--and usually the films are mostly deadly serious. Only two films are serious this year and NONE are about death, Nazis or other sad stuff! As I said, it's an unusual year. Now I am not complaining--this might just be the most enjoyable group of films I've seen in years.This story is interesting in that you see two separate storied that eventually merge. It begins with a man and his friends walking along the shore--picking up mussels and other shellfish to sell. And, at the same time also in Ireland, you see a man coming back to his homeland after many years--and he brings his daughter with him. However, despite meeting all these old friends, there is a nagging problem--and it involves the beachcomber you see at the beginning of the tale.As I said above, if I were the type person to gamble, I'd put my money on "The Shore" to be the Oscar-winner this year. Now this ISN'T to say it was necessarily the most enjoyable or that the other films were poor--but "The Shore" was the best overall package. It had it all. The story was very complex--rewarding and with some wonderful twists. The acting was lovely throughout. The story looked very cinematic--and the direction was very deft. There was simply nothing that could stand improvement. And, I kept my interest throughout.UPDATE: Well, I wish I WAS a betting man as, indeed, "The Shore" did win the Oscar this year.