gorthu Not often will you see a kung fu movie this well directed. Almost a perfect movie. This is the same director who made masterpieces for the Shaw Brothers like Secret Service of the Imperial Court and Bastard Swordsman. Though director TOny Liu has absolutely zero budget here, he doesn't let that stop him. He gets amazing performances from all of his actors. It is a dark movie. The cops are crooked, the heroes are poor, and bad things happen to all of them. The one flaw about this movie is that the story is about a missing dog. The cops want a retarded man to confess, but he doesn't know anything about the dog. I just don't see how I'm supposed to believe that all this fuss is over a dog. But if you can get past that, everything in this movie is perfect. The final fight is spectacular. The villain from Drunken Master, HWang Jang Lee, gives IMO his finest kicking performance in this movie. There's a raw energy in the final fight that will force any action/fight fan to watch in amazement. Just remember to breathe.

phillip-58 According to my Vengeance video case this story is based on actual events that took place in Shanghai 1919. And that is the key to this film. 90% of the film is a drama about several Chinese being framed by the local police (led by Hwang Jang Lee) over the loss of a gwailo's Boxer dog. For the period the photography and direction are rather good with the help of authentic buildings and locations and only limited use of sets. The bad news is that the subtitles are almost unreadable and the film doesn't seem to have been restored and is grainy at times with fluctuating light and colour levels. But the story is gripping and when Philip Ko does fight they are very good indeed. In fact the final fight between Ko and Hwang is very evenly matched and both seem to be on superb form producing an outstanding bout with a clever ending. I must mention Lau Hok Nin's acting and the old mother Lam Jing who give very good dramatic performances not even seen in this sort of film. This is not your usual hit everything / everyone film but a good drama with one of the best climax fights ever filmed.

hmmdrmike Tiger Over Wall has several seriously flawed battle scenes where you can noticeably tell that actors are falling over before actually being "hit." Though I guess you shouldn't watch any karate movie with a sense of absolute reality, the poorly choreographed fight scenes do detract a lot from the viewing experience. Overall though, the movie is still good.The plot is inane and I'll spare you the details. The dialogue is poor and the character's poorly developed. All in all you're supposed to feel sympathetic towards the Ko and hate the police chief (I forget his name). The entire movie is a built around the final fight scene between Ko and the chief... and this scene along saves the movie.How does a movie with a nonsensical plot and bad fight scenes garner a 6 vote? Who knows... but it somehow does. A good film 70's martial arts film... but not a great one.

jrat6200 Like no other, Mr. Silver Fox himself, Hwang Jang Lee, has done it again. With Philip Ko as the protagonist and Mr. Silver Fox with his usual villainous on screen presence. Basically, revenge is the motive in this octane action flick. Of course, I admit that the story is flat except for the simplicity of the plot. Plot Breakdown:-Someone has a missing dog-Hwang Jang Lee plays a corrupt official who tries to gain power and territory-Lee locks up one of Ko's family members for pure torture-Ko handles his business like a man and beats down everyone affiliated with Lee-Long climatic battle between hero and villain (y'all know which is which)It is stated that Hwang Jang Lee choreographed the fight scenes. All I have to say is that I'm very impressed with this man's work. Whether he's acting, producing, or choreographing, he's one of the best at what he does. The action scenes throughout the movie were pretty good. Philip Ko puts on a serious "kick a**" face when he's exploding on enemies. Lee does the same thing, but with more emphasis on legs. Both are brutal and hard-to-the-core. Remember though, there is no character development or emphasis on plot. Who cares!! The producers and the director of this film knew what they were doing. Wicked martial arts action is what I crave, and Hwang Jang Lee along with Philip Ko are just the ones to deliver it.The last fight scene, in my opinion, should go down in cinematic martial arts history. As an avid viewer and aficionado of HK cinema, I would expect a board or big review of this movie. The reviewer before me is right though. Buy the movie for action only. You won't regret it. There is a second movie on the DVD version. The DVD version is a double feature. It is called Goose Boxer. Philip Ko is the villain. Not a very good edition to the DVD. Stick with TIGER OVER WALL!!Final Judgement: ***1/2/****