DesiBaba It has been a while since a really good movie came out of the Bhatt clan, the likes of Naam. There is no doubt they are a talented bunch. They have spotted and nurtured a gem in Aurag Basu. This movie easily catapults Anurag Basu to Tier 1 directors in Bollywood right next to the Bhansalis and the Bharatdwaj's of the industry. Casting is perfect, Shiny Ahuja is excellent as Daya. Kanagana and Gulshan Grover also delivery their roles quite well. Emraan is so so, not too bad compared to some of his other roles. Loved the subtleties and attention to detail throughout the movie such as addict searching through the trash for that one bottle with little left over or the content on Daya's face after earning his first pay from manual labor when he shares soup and bread with Simran. I have not seen a movie that maintains the intensity of this movie through majority of the movie.Screenplay and dialogs are also exceptionally well thought out, like "USKI KHAMOSHI KO MEIN KAI DINO TAK MEHSUS KARTI RAHI" or "MEIN UDHAAR KI EES TASVEER KO APNI ZINDGI BANANA CHAHTI THI". Background score is one of the best in recent times. Not to be missed. . I have not enjoyed a Bollywood movie as much in decades; YMMV. Can't wait for Kites.

silvan-desouza Usually people say Bhatt films have lot of sex, hit music, titillation and no story But this film and some more proved them wrong Actually that 4 things suit Yashraj films moreGangster is one of the best films from Vishesh filmsThe story sounds complicated but the director and screenplay writers make the film one experience to cherishThe love story between Shiny- Kangana, Kangana suddenly falling for Emraan and then her confusion whom to choose and the betrayalAll is handled very well by Anurag BasuThe emotional breakdown of Shiny and the climax is one of the best written scenesAnurag Basu gives his best work so far Music(Pritam) was superb, especially Ya Ali, Bheegi Bheegi, Tu Hi Meri Cinematography made the film more appealing Performances Kangana was one of today's rare heroines, she made her debut in such a spectacular way that all remained stunned and she earned a big name with this film, except her diction and her shouting at placesShiny Ahuja was amazing in his role and performed brilliantly He got least dialogs but did a great job with expressions His emotional breakdown towards the end is one of the best part of the filmEmraan Hashmi surprised, he gave a restrained performance and didn't overact or make funny expressions even once as he normally doesGulshan Grover got a wonderful role and he did a great job despite being a short role

rsa5387 One of the best Bollywood films of 2006, Gangster is an emotionally charged gritty love story that takes its place as one of the best Indian gangster films ever made, and one of the finest films of 2006, Bollywood or not. On the surface, the film fol...(read more) lows a simple story of a woman (Kangana Ranaut) who falls in love with a man who turns out to be a notorious criminal (Shiny Ahuja), and the consequences of that decision inadvertently lead to a lifestyle she grows to discern. Frustrated with her current situation, she eventually falls into the arms of another man (Emraan Hashmi). Beyond this simple story, what happens next through the narratives many twists and turns makes Gangster a film that will not only entertain, but touch your heart as well. While the film possesses a powerful story, its trump card is the films emotionally charged performances. Kangana Ranaut makes her debut as Simran, and is a revelation. She deserved a best debut win and an actress nod for this, if no t for her other release last year, Woh Lamhe. Emraan Hashmi is excellent but underused as Aakash. This is primarily because he doesn't have too much to do for the first half. He shines in the second half. His best acting stint too date. But the real star of the film is Shiny Ahuja. He is absolutely outstanding as the gangster. The flashback scene, the scene where he breaks down in Kanganas lap, and his violent outburst towards the end of the first half are highlights of the film. This role was definitely award-worthy, its criminal he didn't garner any for it. Shiny has proved, in a short time, that he is an actor of enormous caliber. One of the finest performances of 2006, India or not. Beyond acting, the other star is the soundtrack. A massive hit when it released, its a pity the film wasn't as well received as its haunting score. All the songs are shot well (especially Lamhe Lamhe) and are well placed in the film. As always, the direction is well done by Anurag Basu. He proves hes a director of substance after 2003's moving Saaya. The cinematography is well done. Seoul's photogenic locations are put too good use. Overall, Gangster is one of the strongest Hindi films of 2006, and its well worth checking out.

Rafal Jeczmyk (cartaphilius) I'm really amazed how many people writing almost poems about this movie, which is boring copy of a copy of a copy. Script is bad and unoriginal, acting pathetic. And I can call director a scene-stealer. Compare the beginning of Gangster with the beginning of Fallen Angels by Kar Wai Wong - even music is almost the same. The only good thing about this movie is that it didn't last for usual three bollywood hours, but even this two hours was very very long...... Thanks God only two. My principle is that I'm watching movie till the end and after that I'm making judgment. So here it is. Oscar for this? Rather Golden Razzie. Beware. 3/10 only