n-mo Christian Carion is not a prolific filmmaker, but the efforts he does make are noble and display, for the most part, a high level of technical directorial competence despite his relative inexperience. There are of course a few flaws, in this case the hamminess of Diane Kruger and especially Benno Fürmann in two of the lead roles. But although each *part* is made with loving care, on the whole his films seem to lack any sort of grandiose vision or context.Having met and talked (briefly) with Carion my impression is that he is a very kind and very humble man with an earnest desire to see good triumph both in life and on film yet a healthy degree of skepticism as to the capacity of this world to "work things out." I also suspect, however, that he is something of a perfectionist and not perhaps wholly self-confident: there are moments in his films, such as this one, which appear artificial and overly-polished.And I think part of this stems from the fact that Carion tries earnestly to work in a context that he does not fully understand. In the case of Joyeux Noël, Carion tries and unfortunately fails - though his is a much noble failure than that of Jean-Pierre Jeunet in the deliberately commercial "A Very Long Engagement" - to capture the spirit and atmosphere of 1910s Europe. He fails - but he deserves credit for nearly succeeding. Other contemporary filmmakers would have taken the subject of the Christmas Truce and created a banal lesson about top-down bureaucratic WORLD PEACE that would make Eleanor Roosevelt proud. Carion does not succumb to the temptation to do so.Nor does Carion - who was apparently a "seeking" nonbeliever when I met him in 2006 - neglect to amply depict - as James Cameron neglected to do in "Titanic" - the still ubiquitous presence of Christian belief, ritual and cultural referential in the Western society of that time. However, he fails to bind this Christian culture and energy to the characters, and in so doing he fails to provide an important aspect of the context in which the historical Christmas Truce took place: the common religious, ethical and cultural referentials were still strong enough to provide, if only for a moment, a solid covering of chivalry.Not that he doesn't try. Hints are given as to the respective family and parochial lives of the major characters from respectively Scotland, France and Germany, but not nearly enough. Carion doesn't seem comfortable trying to flesh these out more: if he is trying to respect the rule that a writer should stick to writing what he knows, then the film is better off for it. Regrettably, though, the dearth of cultural context means that anyone not already deeply initiated in European history and the Christmas Truce - or even, after a few successive viewings, someone who is - will find that the film seems... small, much smaller and less significant than its subject matter. This WAS, after all, the "War to End Wars," and the truce involved hundreds of thousands of troops along the trenches. Yet Carion never expands outward from the cannon-fodder layer of wartime society - a Christmas Peace had been requested by Pope Benedict XV and rebuffed by the military commanders - and so we never get a sense of the drama or the moral significance of the events.I would say that "Joyeux Noël" is on the whole a failure, but it is a noble failure, one that should provide hints for a jumping off point when somewhere down the road someone decides to paint a more grandiose picture of this under-appreciated happening. But if such an honest and tasteful filmmaker as Carion cannot penetrate deeply enough into the more primordial imagination of the period to portray it more fully, it is questionable whether a truly satisfying and earnest portrayal of the Peace can ever be realized in the modern world.

WakenPayne The reason why I decided to sit down and watch this movie is because I heard about it and decided that it looked like an interesting movie and certainly one which will demonstrate the pointlessness of stuff like this. When I found it I decided to sit down and watch it and this movie succeeds in what it was trying to do.The plot is that as the French, German and Scottish armies are fighting World War One, they all decide one night to cease fire - Christmas Eve. As the sides come out of their trenches they share photographs, items such as champagne and have a musical performance by German opera singers (one who happens to be in the war, the other is his girlfriend) and a mass. The next day they can't go through with killing people who a few hours ago were considered friends. They then decide to hold the cease fire for a little longer to collect dead bodies and bury them and after that they have a football match.There are a few complaints with this movie so I'll just list them. The action is awful. I know it might be a nitpick because there is only 2 action scenes in this movie but it's the kind where I had no idea what is going on. I would also say it is easy to tell that Diane Kruger and Benno Furmann were dubbed in their singing voices, I mean both do pull through really good performances but this is really obvious.Everything else however is really good, I'd say one of my favourite scenes in this movie is when the medic/priest is asked to go back to the parish by another, higher priest and then the higher priest gives a sermon on why killing the Germans who they once considered friends is good, and this isn't an over-the-top shout (nor is any other person who tries to say killing the opposing sides they shared stuff with is a good thing).The acting is fantastic, the writing is really good and so is the directing and the cinematography. Everything the movie wants to say is said really well and it was certainly right to give it a nomination for best foreign language film (although how did that work when three languages are spoken and they're pretty well evened out).My advice is if you want something to watch for Christmas this year then this is certainly one I'd suggest you'd consider. If you're an atheist or non-Christian (which I am) then I'd also suggest checking this one out. If you like War movies then this doesn't really have the action of one but it does have the drama of one. If you're looking for some kind of blend then I'd also suggest this.

Syl Joyeux Noel or Merry Christmas should be shown every year on television. It is beautiful movie about the true meaning of Christmas. The director does a brilliant job in depicting three military units like the Germans, French, and the Scottish who are fighting the first Christmas away from their loved ones and facing an invisible enemy. While they stop and have informal and unauthorized ceasefire on Christmas Eve. The soldiers whether German, Scottish, or French begin a platonic fraternization of brotherhood. It's nice to see a film about war that isn't. As they become friends, they share good times even for a brief time. Their leaders will face the consequences of resisting to continue battling in no mans land. Yet there are beautiful moments like when they start singing together and playing music. It's still a great film and should be viewed around the holiday season.

p_couture@hotmail.com I remember seeing this movie in theaters almost 7 years ago, during the Holidays, and falling under its spell almost instantly.The main element of the story, unknown to me at that time, was that soldiers on both sides of the War decided to call a truce on that night. And the following morning. Until...Like the title to this review says: How common sense almost prevailed. Almost. I won't go into spoilers here, I'll simply add that this movie is a reminder of the true meaning of Christmas, and how we need to find hope and common sense in each other in the heart of madness. Considering the recent events in Newtown CT, I think that's more appropriate than ever.The acting is good, but I give special props to Gary Lewis, Dany Boon and Daniel Bruhl in their respective roles. Production values are good too. Best of all, the music.