KMKSouthie2001
This movie, and basically all movies based in or about South Boston are an utter disgrace. This movie, and all movies based in or about Southie, are a horribly inaccurate portrayal of a wonderful neighborhood. No, the Irish Mafia does not run Southie. In reality, Southie is generally a safe place to live. I've lived here in Southie all my life and I find movies based in or about Southie as an insult to Southie and it's residents. Movies like this are just a waste of time, not to mention painfully bad to watch just because of the sheer fact that the movie is just so INACCURATE. Even if this particular movie wasn't based in Southie, it would still be a horrible movie just because of it's utterly poor acting. Talk about a waste of a movie studio's money. Not to mention that all attempts at a Bostonian accent in this movie are so bad that they're painful to listen too. If you're not from Boston, don't even attempt to try to talk like us. Just don't, because you'll make a complete fool of yourself.
aimless-46
After watching 'Southie' I was surprised at its low rating on the IMDb; and somewhat puzzled because almost everyone who took the time to post a comment found it an excellent film. Although in overall effect it is not on the level of 'Mean Streets', it a still a very solid production; on the level of "Monument Avenue" and "The Friends of Eddie Coyle". I suppose that a rather ordinary screenplay and a downbeat ending put some people off.But this small film did a fine job of presenting a believable (if troubled) family, it utilized some interesting (out of favor) camera techniques to advance the storyline, and it showcased some excellent acting. It is refreshing to watch something without a hint of computer generated crap. If your production fundmentals are sound you don't need that kind of distraction.There are two diametrically opposite scenes between Donnie Wahlberg and Rose McGowan that work so well that you wonder why they didn't alter the script to expand McGowan's part . One is in an Irish bar where Danny convinces his sister to enter an in-patient alcohol treatment program. The other is a few days later when he visits her in the middle of the program. The contrast between the intensity levels of these two scenes is amazing and McGowan pulls off the dramatic performance of her career. She is great at comedy but in these scenes she shows unexpected dramatic range. 'Southie' would be worth watching for just these two scenes but it is a solid effort from start to finish. Highly recommended.
SpringsteenRules
I rented this movie because I read the box too quickly and thought it starred Marc Wahlburg, not Donnie. When I got it home my wife asked me who Donnie was and I realized my mistake. However, I was very pleased with my mistake. This was a very good movie. A real family, good vs. bad and even small time mob interests. No nudity for those interested in that sort of thing.Rose McGowen's acting was very good. Also, she looks gorgeous even when she's made up to look like a white trash alcoholic. The characters' accents do sometimes slip in and out with the exception of Donnie who is from Boston in real life.All in all, it was a very good movie.
yorkbj-2
I was completely amazed by Southie. I was expecting a movie where Donnie Wahlberg was the center of attention and the action focused around drawn out, bloody battles. To my surprise it wasn't. The story line was interesting and the cast seemed like they were all meant to be together. If you can get past the "New Kids on the Block" Donnie Wahlberg mentality, Southie is an excellent movie worthy of the award it has won and many more.
AD
