JohnHowardReid
Aside from its shoot-out climax on horseback, this is an undistinguished little formula western. Oswald's direction is extremely routine with its long takes, static camera angles, plus a decided emphasis on uninspired close-ups, principally of wooden-faced Hugh O'Brian.The acting is as lethargic as the dialog is cliched. The characters are one-dimensional and with one or two exceptions (such as Burr's jaded killer, Tassell's ruthless saloon girl), the playing lacks sparkle, although it's nice to see Russell Sinpson as Pop Jackson (one of the jailers) and Norman Leavitt as a deputy who even covers out hero in a saloon shoot-out.Production values are very moderate, and credits undistinguished. In fact there is a great deal of very obvious day-for-night shooting!
bkoganbing
There seems to be a lot of the same kind of people that inhabit the town that Hugh O'Brian is the sheriff of as there were in High Noon where Gary Cooper was the law. O'Brian gets about the same amount and kind of support that Cooper did.The Brass Legend has Sheriff O'Brian getting a tip from young Donald MacDonald that notorious outlaw Raymond Burr is in the area and keeping company with a lewd saloon woman Rebecca Welles. Before they get down to business O'Brian has the drop on Burr.Well by God this is not according to the code of the west where you're supposed to face the bad guy down and maybe get killed. Bad enough that Welles believes it and makes no secret about it, but half the town thinks like she does and thinks that Burr got a raw deal. Further they don't like that O'Brian tried to keep young MacDonald's name out of it thinking that one of Burr's friends might want to shoot the snitch even if he's 12 years old. Sure enough a particular low life specimen does.O'Brian is a stalwart hero in the mold of Wyatt Earp whom he just started playing on television. Burr is always an interesting villain and Welles as the vengeful saloon woman is fascinating.The Brass Legend a good B western, fans of O'Brian and Burr will not be disappointed.
MartinHafer
Hugh O'Brien plays Sheriff Addams--one of the few inhabitants of a stupid old west town. I say stupid because the folks don't seem all that bright and they seem to appreciate their sheriff about as much you'd appreciate Eczema! Clay Gipson is a 12 year-old who happens to see the wanted killer, Tris Hatten (Raymond Burr). When he tells the sheriff, Addams is able to capture the baddie. Oddly, many of the townsfolk seem to feel sorry for Hatten--even though he's killed several people! As I said, it's a very stupid town!! So, the trick is to bring Hatten to trial and convict him--while at the same time Addams and Gipson remain alive to see it! But, the conspiracy of stupids is strong!! The biggest weakness of this film is how fickle and stupid the townspeople were--a bit too stupid if you ask me. I also thought a few of the characters were ridiculous--such as Hatten's girlfriend (???). Clay's father wasn't much better. But, O'Brien does a nice job as does Burr--who is always great in baddie roles. On balance, worth seeing but far from a must-see picture.
classicsoncall
With Raymond Burr forever etched in the minds of TV watchers as lawyer Perry Mason, it's somewhat uncharacteristic to see him toting a handgun as the main heavy in a sagebrush yarn like "The Brass Legend". He looks the part too, all gruff and unruly, and perhaps with a girth I hadn't noticed before. Hugh O'Brian looks just right for the part of a sheriff, whether here as Wade Addams, or as the lead character in "The Life and Legend of Wyatt Earp". Can you believe that series is over fifty years old?For a Western that follows a fairly standard formula, director Gerd Oswald provides some interesting scenes that were never staples of the genre. Like young Tom Gipson (Robert Burton) getting shot off his horse, or how about that fancy showdown in the saloon when the Sheriff takes out all three Barlow brothers? That scene came off as totally realistic, vindicating Addams' tarnished reputation in bringing outlaw Tris Hatten (Burr) to justice in the first place. Even the ending was done differently, instead of your standard showdown in the middle of a dusty street, you have both antagonists riding toward each other like jousting knights, but with guns blazing instead. There seemed to be just the right amount of satisfaction in Hatten's dying breath as he figures he outlived the hangman.But you know, I keep wondering about one scene. How many takes do you think it required for Burr to find his mark when he threw his holstered gun against the wall?
AD
