roger-bateson1
Tipped off by Uncut magazine this was well worth the wait and, although mixed with the joy that is the music of Gene Clark and the sadness that he flew from us too early, or perhaps too high like Icarus, I approached this DVD with some trepidation in fear of tainting my misty memories. No cause for concern though as, albeit with limited footage available, the producers have gathered together a fitting tribute encompassing the insight of fellow Byrds, wife and family, friends and fellow journeymen troubadours. Thank you! After watching the film and delving through the extras, most of which warrant inclusion, it only led me to dig out all the old vinyl and indulge and immerse once more. Pride of place went to listening to and pouring over my signed copies of White Light, but especially my Dutch pressing of Roadmaster which back in 1976 I think it was at the Leeds Uni McGuinn Clark Hillman gig, provoked the response from the great man of "Did I make this?" as he had never seen the sleeve before. Suffice to say our ten minutes conversation was a time to treasure on my part.Perhaps I am preaching to the already converted but if anyone has any interest in probably the most enigmatic Byrd then do not hesitate to watch this worthy film.And in conclusion, yes, "No Other" is still firmly ensconced in my top 5 albums of all time!
letshaveanotherbeer
This was great! I had a feeling beforehand how good it might be when I saw the list of the participants who appeared in it. Getting McGuinn,Hillman and Crosby to talk was the clincher all around in my opinion.Thankfully they made a documentary that was straightforward and focused on Gene and all facets of his story as it was, not turning into something different like the Oliver Stone Doors movie. Ray Manzarek continually ridiculed that movie and what a missed opportunity it was.Not here. It was really nice to see participation from not only other musicians, but Gene's family members as well.It's great when you've been a fan of someone and they get a tribute like this. And just as great is that Gene's music is still getting rediscovered.
chrissables
Although lacking certain dynamics; I found this film incredibly moving. It almost felt like a family history, contributions from Gene's lovely sister and brother and his two sons made this feel so intimate and up close. A very warm human story with some great contributions, you can almost wait for the tide to come in and go out while David Crosby finds the very most appropriate words to describe Gene's...soul. It is clear that Gene Clark had a profound effect on just about everyone he met. I also found it a valuable guide on how to grow old gracefully, or graciously - some fantastic insights and wisdom from Gene's former band mates, Chris Hillman deserves a special mention as the guy you would probably most wish to be like when in your mid-late sixties. I learn't a lot by watching this film and felt enriched by the experience. An extremely worthy tribute to a mercurial, searching, cosmic American dreamer.
tokyor88
"TBWFA" so exceeding my expectations. I was so sad when it was over though the extras were quite good as well. Having known Gene a little and having seen him perform live many times, this was a treasure for a much missed performer and acquaintance. Having produced TV, music videos, and studied documentary making, I know how hard it is to achieve the level of excellence that "TBWFA" has hit. I only regret that pictures I took of Gene didn't make their way into the project because of a communication snafu. As a side note, I was surprised and delighted at the candor of all the interviewees, both positive and negative towards Gene.Especially nice to see David Crosby finally cop to Gene's genius as a writer and vocalist. That was a long time coming.Enjoy if you haven't watched it yet!Peace, Toke
AD
