JoeytheBrit This Laurel & Hardy silent only exists in an incomplete version which naturally makes it impossible to judge as a whole. As it exists today, it's pretty much like two separate films joined by some explanatory intertitles (featuring a still of a young and rather slim-line Eugene Palette selling the boys some insurance). The first section of the film is a boxing match between a paunchy Stan and a typically ferocious opponent. The boxing ring seemed to be a favourite location for the boys – I'm sure there's at least three movies which feature Stan involved in a hopeless mismatch in the ring. The second section of the film is the famous pie fight, but unfortunately not enough of it exists to give anything other than an incomplete impression of what the boys intended. The film's interesting as a peep through the keyhole of what remains of what has been lost (if you know what I mean) but it's not particularly satisfying in its own right.

Jackson Booth-Millard Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy are the most famous comedy duo in history, and deservedly so, so I am happy to see any of their films. In a boxing ring, the predicted winner Thunder-Clap Callahan (Noah Young) is about to fight less impressive looking Canvasback Clump, aka The Human Mop (Stan), and the audience blow raspberries at him and his Manager (Ollie). If they win they get $100, and if they lose they get $5, but it is obvious Clump is very slow witted, he doesn't move from the middle after the Referee (Sam Lufkin) explains the rules to them. Clump sees Callahan jumping in his corner to warn up, he assumes he's dancing, so he improvises some ballet-like stuff in his corner, till he falls. Then Clump is jumping around and swinging his fists ready to fight, his Manager advising him to use his left fist, and when the bell goes, he manages to unintentionally knock Callahan out with his left holding his arm out. The Referee can't finish the countdown till Clump is sat down, and the misunderstanding turn into a little scuffle between them, till he does sit down and Callahan comes round. After a quick fall and near countdown, Clump is ready for another round, but it ends very quickly when Callahan knocks him out, and his Manager faints too, and when he comes round, the whole audience has left, and Clump is sleeping on the ring floor. In the missing footage, a man at the fight recognises Clump, and his Manager buys accident insurance on his behalf, and they try to get money from this insurance by the Manager placing a banana peel on the floor for Clump to slip on. Instead, a Pie Delivery Man (Charlie Hall) slips on it, and presses one of his custard pies in the Manager's face, and when he throws two back, one hits the backside, and the second the face of a woman (Dorothy Coburn). She throws one back, and hits a man having his shows shined, and soon many other people, including a man in a top hat, a dentist patient, a sewer man hole guy, a pie shop customer and a barber shop customer are joining in, while a postman and a man posing for a photo get some pie too. Eventually the boys move away from the chaos, and Stan's last pie goes on the floor, for a woman (Anita Garvin) to slip on, and the rest of the missing film would have the boys questioned by a policeman about how the fight going all the way down the street started, and him chasing them away getting a pie in the face. Filled with good slapstick and all classic comedy you want from a black and white silent film, it is easily the shortest, but it is an enjoyable film. Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy were number 7 on The Comedians' Comedian. Worth watching!

proffate Unfortunately, the film is incomplete. Much of the first reel, with Stan Laurel as a prizefighter, has been lost.What remains is one of film's most inventive pie fights. As the story goes, the writers, director and cast were discussing how to end the short when somebody suggested throwing a few pies.Laurel jumped on this idea. "If we're going to throw pies, let's throw *lots* of pies!" So it began....The gags are highly creative. A dentist's patient gets hit while he's helpless with his mouth open. An attractive flapper takes a pie on her vulnerable behind while climbing into a car. When she turns to protest, she gets another in the face. The traditional dowager catches a pie as she peers through her lorgnette at the melee. The final gag has stately Anita Garvin doing a pratfall onto a dropped pie. Uncertain what she's fallen into, she darts around the corner, pausing only to shake one leg along the way.The best place to find the pie fight is on Robert Youngson's "The Golden Age of Comedy."

WCFIELDS I viewed a restored version of "The Battle of The Century", put out on video by Nostalgia Archives. Prior to this I had only seen a sequence of a few minutes from the Robert Youngson compilation, "When Comedy Was King". This is a truly funny film, for it shows Laurel and Hardy at their best. The pie in the face was kind of old hat even for 1928. But Hal Roach using Laurel and Hardy created the funniest pie fight of all time. All the different scenarios that were used to deliver the pies as well as a generous helping of laughs has an almost ballet rhythm to it. There was of course to help the madness along, both Charley Hall and Anita Garvin a couple of Hal Roach Regulars. As I said, this film was considered "lost" however the first reel was found and the film is complete except for a couple of minutes of film that are still missing from the start of the second reel. However this was compensated for by a combination of still photos that are intercut with the continuity script. I was very pleased with the film and I am sure any person interested in the silent comedy shorts would also enjoy this fine film that has been carefully reconstructed.